Moms for Liberty and Young America’s Foundation, et al. v. U.S. Department of Education

SLF Represents Moms for Liberty and Young America's Foundation in Title IX Lawsuit

About the Case

In May 2024, Moms for Liberty and Young America’s Foundation sued the Biden Administration to stop its overhaul of Title IX—an unconstitutional attempt to gut Title IX’s guarantee that America’s schools afford girls the same opportunities as boys and protect girls and boys with sex-separate private spaces like bathrooms and locker rooms. Represented by Southeastern Legal Foundation (SLF), the two organizations assert the claims on behalf of their members whose First Amendment rights are being trampled by the Biden Department of Education’s new regulation, which threatens to punish students for voicing their beliefs in biological sex and forces them to affirm views on gender fluidity, transgenderism, and queer theory.

They are joined by the states of Kansas, Wyoming, Utah, and Alaska in the lawsuit, which aims at stopping the Department of Education’s blatant disregard for the First Amendment rights of K-12 and college students.

Read More

Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 prohibit discrimination on the basis of sex in schools and educational programs. It was passed into law by Congress, and it ensures that girls and women are afforded the same educational opportunities as boys and men, while at the same time recognizing that sex-separated facilities such as restrooms and locker rooms are necessary to protect their dignity and privacy.

But within days of taking office, President Biden and his administration started gutting these protections. Biden issued an Executive Order unilaterally changing the definition of “sex” to include “gender identity” and ordered the Department of Education to rewrite Title IX regulations to forever remove equal access and other legal protections. Soon after, the Department of Education proposed changes to Title IX, claiming it had authority to do so as part of its rulemaking powers.

The Department of Education sought to change the definition of “sex” to include gender identity, lower the standard for finding harassment, force individuals to use incorrect pronouns that are not based on biology, and centralize all investigative and disciplinary authority under one campus Title IX coordinator.

SLF challenged the Department of Education’s proposed changes through formal administrative public comment and testimony. But the Department of Education forged ahead and ignored the public’s concerns, issuing a final rule (the “Biden Rule”) in late April 2024, which Moms for Liberty and Young America’s Foundation now challenge in court. SLF and Mountain States Legal Foundation (MSLF) are representing these parents and students free of charge in their fight for freedom.

In their lawsuit, the states and organizations argue that the Biden Rule violates the Administrative Procedure Act and separation of powers because the Department of Education changed Title IX without congressional authority; that the Rule violates students’ First Amendment rights because it will compel them to affirm other students’ so-called “gender identity” and discriminates against opposing views; and that the Rule violates other provisions of the Constitution, including the Spending Clause and the Tenth Amendment.

The states and organizations are asking the Kansas federal court to declare the Biden Rule unlawful and unconstitutional and to stop its enforcement.

Case Status

Active

Court

District of Kansas

Why This Matters

The Biden Department of Education has taken bold, unprecedented moves to capture America’s schools. It consistently acts outside the scope of its powers, ignoring Congress and even the courts, to fulfill President Biden’s political agenda. The Department’s drastic overhaul of Title IX—including rewriting the very definition of “sex” set forth by Congress—is perhaps its most unprecedented and unconstitutional move yet.

The Biden Rule will have an especially devastating impact on freedom of speech in colleges and K-12 schools.

Members of Young America’s Foundation speak about current political and social issues, including topics related to gender identity, transgenderism, and de-transitioning. They want to continue engaging with their classmates on these topics and hosting speakers to discuss these topics. They fear that under the new rule, they cannot continue their speech activities because they will be reported for harassment.

Members of Moms for Liberty are the parents of children in K-12 schools. They believe, and they have instilled in their children the belief, that all human beings are created male and female, that gender and sex are not fluid concepts, and that sex cannot be changed. However, their children fear that under the new rule, they will be forced to acknowledge their classmates’ so-called gender identity, use incorrect pronouns, and share private spaces with members of the opposite sex.

It is not up to the federal government to determine how parents should raise their children or what sort of beliefs and values a society should hold. But by imposing a gender identity orthodoxy on all of America, the Biden Administration is attempting to do just that.

Moms for Liberty Co-founders Tiffany Justice and Tina Descovich state,

Parental rights do not end at the classroom door. Every parent in America is about to see biological boys on girls’ sports teams and in girls’ locker rooms; and gender identity and sexual orientation will be taught in every classroom across America, whether parents like it or not. . . . Our children go to public school. They do not belong to public school. That is something we will never stop fighting to prove, even if it means going toe-to-toe against the heavy-handed ‘gender identity’ mandates from the Biden Administration.

Vice President and General Counsel for Young America’s Foundation Victor Bernson states,

Gender ideology is a bald-faced lie, men are men and women are women. With its new Title IX rules, the Biden administration is forcing everyone in college across the nation to repeat and live the lie that men can be women. It’s unconscionable. This lawsuit is YAF’s opportunity to stand with our students on the side of truth and against those who would pervert it.

 

In the News

Moms for Liberty, Young America’s Foundation, GOP states sue feds for Title IX gender identity rule (Just the News)

Moms for Liberty sues Biden administration over ‘outrageous’ Title IX overhaul (Washington Examiner)

Young America’s Foundation joins with state Attorneys General in lawsuit to stop Biden’s unconstitutional Title IX changes (Yahoo Finance)

4 GOP-led states sue administration over Title IX rules for transgender students (The Hill)

Moms for Liberty sues Biden Admin to stop Title IX rule changes (Tampa Free Press)

Moms for Liberty challenges Biden Administration’s Title IX regulations (War Room)

Moms for Liberty sues Biden over ‘outrageous’ Title IX rewrite (Off the Press)

More conservative groups join legal battle against Biden’s ‘radical’ Title IX rewrite (College Fix)

‘Crazy gaslighting’: Foes of Biden gender identity mandate predict strength in numbers, court wins (Just the News)

LISTEN

Kimberly Hermann breaks down Title IX changes with Network of Enlightened Women (Conservative Women’s Guide)

SLF’s Kimberly Hermann joins the Wilkow Majority (Wilkow Majority)

SLF breaks down legal challenges to new Title IX rule (John Solomon Reports)

SLF’s Cece O’Leary joins Jeff Stein to discuss Title IX lawsuit (Iowa Politics with Jeff Stein)

WATCH

SLF client and Moms for Liberty Co-Founder Tiffany Justice discusses lawsuit challenging Biden’s Title IX overhaul (One America News)

Title IX controversy CHANGES biological definitions? (The First)

SLF’s Kimberly Hermann joins Lou Dobbs to discuss Biden Administration’s disregard for students’ and parents’ rights (The Great America Show)

Moms for Liberty, Southeastern Legal Foundation, and Heritage Foundation discuss Biden’s Title IX overhaul (Joyful Warriors Podcast)

Why This Matters

The Biden Department of Education has taken bold, unprecedented moves to capture America’s schools. It consistently acts outside the scope of its powers, ignoring Congress and even the courts, to fulfill President Biden’s political agenda. The Department’s drastic overhaul of Title IX—including rewriting the very definition of “sex” set forth by Congress—is perhaps its most unprecedented and unconstitutional move yet.

The Biden Rule will have an especially devastating impact on freedom of speech in colleges and K-12 schools.

Members of Young America’s Foundation speak about current political and social issues, including topics related to gender identity, transgenderism, and de-transitioning. They want to continue engaging with their classmates on these topics and hosting speakers to discuss these topics. They fear that under the new rule, they cannot continue their speech activities because they will be reported for harassment.

Members of Moms for Liberty are the parents of children in K-12 schools. They believe, and they have instilled in their children the belief, that all human beings are created male and female, that gender and sex are not fluid concepts, and that sex cannot be changed. However, their children fear that under the new rule, they will be forced to acknowledge their classmates’ so-called gender identity, use incorrect pronouns, and share private spaces with members of the opposite sex.

It is not up to the federal government to determine how parents should raise their children or what sort of beliefs and values a society should hold. But by imposing a gender identity orthodoxy on all of America, the Biden Administration is attempting to do just that.

Moms for Liberty Co-founders Tiffany Justice and Tina Descovich state,

Parental rights do not end at the classroom door. Every parent in America is about to see biological boys on girls’ sports teams and in girls’ locker rooms; and gender identity and sexual orientation will be taught in every classroom across America, whether parents like it or not. . . . Our children go to public school. They do not belong to public school. That is something we will never stop fighting to prove, even if it means going toe-to-toe against the heavy-handed ‘gender identity’ mandates from the Biden Administration.

Vice President and General Counsel for Young America’s Foundation Victor Bernson states,

Gender ideology is a bald-faced lie, men are men and women are women. With its new Title IX rules, the Biden administration is forcing everyone in college across the nation to repeat and live the lie that men can be women. It’s unconscionable. This lawsuit is YAF’s opportunity to stand with our students on the side of truth and against those who would pervert it.

 

In the News

Moms for Liberty, Young America’s Foundation, GOP states sue feds for Title IX gender identity rule (Just the News)

Moms for Liberty sues Biden administration over ‘outrageous’ Title IX overhaul (Washington Examiner)

Young America’s Foundation joins with state Attorneys General in lawsuit to stop Biden’s unconstitutional Title IX changes (Yahoo Finance)

4 GOP-led states sue administration over Title IX rules for transgender students (The Hill)

Moms for Liberty sues Biden Admin to stop Title IX rule changes (Tampa Free Press)

Moms for Liberty challenges Biden Administration’s Title IX regulations (War Room)

Moms for Liberty sues Biden over ‘outrageous’ Title IX rewrite (Off the Press)

More conservative groups join legal battle against Biden’s ‘radical’ Title IX rewrite (College Fix)

‘Crazy gaslighting’: Foes of Biden gender identity mandate predict strength in numbers, court wins (Just the News)

LISTEN

Kimberly Hermann breaks down Title IX changes with Network of Enlightened Women (Conservative Women’s Guide)

SLF’s Kimberly Hermann joins the Wilkow Majority (Wilkow Majority)

SLF breaks down legal challenges to new Title IX rule (John Solomon Reports)

SLF’s Cece O’Leary joins Jeff Stein to discuss Title IX lawsuit (Iowa Politics with Jeff Stein)

WATCH

SLF client and Moms for Liberty Co-Founder Tiffany Justice discusses lawsuit challenging Biden’s Title IX overhaul (One America News)

Title IX controversy CHANGES biological definitions? (The First)

SLF’s Kimberly Hermann joins Lou Dobbs to discuss Biden Administration’s disregard for students’ and parents’ rights (The Great America Show)

Moms for Liberty, Southeastern Legal Foundation, and Heritage Foundation discuss Biden’s Title IX overhaul (Joyful Warriors Podcast)

Share This